Summary
When an adult in Ontario cannot manage property, or cannot make personal-care decisions, the Substitute Decisions Act, 1992, S.O. 1992, c. 30, sets out who may be appointed, who must receive notice, and how an appointment can be changed. Francis Lawyers specializes in estate litigation, including guardianship disputes, for clients in Ottawa and across Ontario. See estate litigation. A continuing power of attorney is made while the grantor is capable.
What the Substitute Decisions Act says
The Act presumes capacity at eighteen to enter into a contract, and at sixteen to give or refuse consent in connection with one's own personal care (s. 2(1), (2)). "Court" means the Superior Court of Justice (s. 1(1)). Under ss. 6 and 45, a person is incapable if the person is not able to understand information relevant to the decision, or to appreciate the reasonably foreseeable consequences of a decision or lack of decision. Section 45 applies that test to health care, nutrition, shelter, clothing, hygiene and safety.
The Public Guardian and Trustee becomes a statutory guardian of property if a Mental Health Act certificate of incapacity is issued for a psychiatric-facility patient (s. 15), or if an assessor issues a certificate of incapacity and that office receives a copy (s. 16(3), (5)). The person must be told of the appointment and of the right to apply to the Consent and Capacity Board for a review (s. 16(6)). A continuing power of attorney covering all of the person's property can terminate that statutory guardianship if the conditions in s. 16.1 are met.
The court may, on any person's application, appoint a guardian of property where the person is incapable of managing property and, as a result, decisions must be made on the person's behalf (s. 22(1)), even if there is already a statutory guardian (s. 22(2)). The court shall not appoint a guardian if it is satisfied that the need will be met by an alternative course of action that does not require a finding of incapacity and is less restrictive of the person's decision-making rights (s. 22(3)). The same less-restrictive rule applies to a guardian of the person (s. 55(1), (2)). A court appointment under s. 22 terminates a continuing power of attorney (s. 12(1)(c)) and a statutory guardianship (s. 20(1)).
A guardian of property may do on the incapable person's behalf anything in respect of property that the person could do if capable, except make a will (s. 31(1)), and shall act diligently, with honesty and integrity and in good faith, for the incapable person's benefit (s. 32(1)).
Who can apply or object
Any person may apply under s. 22(1) or s. 55(1). The right is not limited to a spouse or relative. A person who provides health care or residential, social, training or support services to the incapable person for compensation shall not be appointed, subject to the exceptions in ss. 24(1), (2) and 57(1)–(2.1). The court shall not appoint the Public Guardian and Trustee unless the application proposes that office, written consent is filed, and no other suitable person is available and willing (ss. 24(2.1), 57(2.2)).
If the Public Guardian and Trustee is already the statutory guardian of property, the persons listed in s. 17(1) (a spouse or partner, a relative, a continuing attorney in the circumstances set out there, or a trust corporation with the required consent) may apply to that office, in the prescribed form and with a management plan, to replace it (s. 17(1)–(3)). Subject to s. 17(6), that office shall appoint the applicant if satisfied the applicant is suitable and the plan appropriate (s. 17(4)).
Notice shall be served on the person alleged to be incapable, the proposed guardian, the Public Guardian and Trustee, and the known attorneys or guardians listed in s. 69(1) or (3), together with the documents required by s. 70, and on known family members listed in s. 69(6) unless s. 69(7) applies.
The application shall include the proposed guardian's consent, a prescribed management plan or guardianship plan (unless the proposed guardian is the Public Guardian and Trustee), and a signed statement that the person alleged to be incapable has been informed of the nature of the application and the right to oppose it, or why that was not possible (s. 70(1), (2)). If capacity is in issue and the person has no legal representation, the court may direct the Public Guardian and Trustee to arrange legal representation, and the person is deemed to have capacity to retain and instruct counsel (s. 3(1)). A motion to vary, substitute or terminate may be made by the guardian, the original applicant, or any person entitled under s. 69 to notice of that proceeding (ss. 26, 28, 61, 63).
The process
An "assessor" is a member of a class designated by the regulations as qualified to do assessments of capacity (s. 1(1)). Subject to s. 78(3), an assessor shall not assess a person who refuses, and shall first explain the purpose, the effect of a finding, and the right to refuse (s. 78(1), (2)). The court may order an assessment if capacity is in issue and there are reasonable grounds to believe the person is incapable (s. 79(1)).
The court may, on application, order that all or a specified part of the accounts of an attorney or guardian of property be passed (s. 42(1)). The attorney or guardian, the grantor or incapable person, and the persons listed in s. 42(4) may apply, including the Public Guardian and Trustee. The court may suspend or terminate the appointment (s. 42(7), (8)).
Practical takeaways
Property and personal care are separate offices, with separate incapacity tests (ss. 6, 45) and appointment powers (ss. 22, 55).
Any person may apply to the court. If the Public Guardian and Trustee is statutory guardian, s. 17(1) allows replacement.
The court shall not appoint a guardian if a less restrictive alternative will meet the need without a finding of incapacity (ss. 22(3), 55(2)).
Notice, a prescribed plan, and a statement about the right to oppose are required (ss. 69, 70).
Accounts can be passed, and an appointment can be varied, substituted or terminated, by the persons the Act names (ss. 26, 28, 42, 61, 63).
Frequently asked questions
Who may apply to the court for a guardianship appointment in Ontario?
The court may appoint a guardian of property or of the person on any person's application (ss. 22(1), 55(1)). The applicant need not be a spouse or relative. Who may be appointed is limited by ss. 24 and 57.
How does a statutory guardian of property differ from a court-appointed guardian?
The Public Guardian and Trustee becomes a statutory guardian of property under s. 15 or s. 16(5). A court-appointed guardian is appointed under s. 22 or s. 55. A court appointment under s. 22 terminates a statutory guardianship (s. 20(1)).
Does a continuing power of attorney block a court appointment?
Not automatically. The court shall not appoint a guardian if a less restrictive alternative will meet the need without a finding of incapacity (ss. 22(3), 55(2)). If the court appoints a guardian of property under s. 22, the continuing power of attorney is terminated (s. 12(1)(c)).
Who must be served, and how can a guardian be replaced?
Notice shall be served as s. 69 requires. The court may order accounts passed (s. 42) and may vary, substitute or terminate the appointment on motion by the guardian, the original applicant, or any person entitled under s. 69 to notice of that proceeding (ss. 26, 28, 61, 63).
Talk to us
Francis Lawyers specializes in estate litigation, including guardianship disputes, for clients in Ottawa and across Ontario. Book a consultation with the lawyers at Francis Lawyers: (613) 226-1011.
General information, not legal advice. This content is about Ontario law as of November 2026. It does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Laws change and every situation is different. Speak with a lawyer about your specific circumstances. Written by the lawyers at Francis Lawyers, Ottawa. Published November 19, 2026.