The case in plain terms
After a parent dies, the family finds years of large payments to a caregiver. Were they gifts?
In Waters Estate v. Henry, Dr. William Waters transferred more than $30 million, on at least 393 occasions over ten years, to Gillian Henry, who had been hired to care for his housebound wife, Phyllis (paras. 1-2, 14). After his death, his estate sued, arguing that most transfers were investments subject to a resulting trust, not gifts (para. 3).
The Court called it "a tale of two narratives": one of a financially sophisticated older man freely transferring money to the woman with whom he was having a clandestine affair, the other of a younger woman using a predatory romance scam to separate him from his money (para. 1). Those are the competing stories, not findings. The central question is "whether the transfers were gifts, or whether they were subject to a resulting trust" (para. 1).
Ms. Henry largely succeeded at trial (para. 4). The Court of Appeal allowed the estate's appeal and ordered a new trial (paras. 7, 45). Nothing has been finally decided about whether the transfers were gifts.
Citation and where to read it
Waters Estate v. Henry, 2026 ONCA 704 (Court of Appeal for Ontario, Huscroft, Zarnett and Pomerance JJ.A.; reasons by Pomerance J.A.; released November 12, 2026).
Official reasons: Court of Appeal for Ontario
What the Court said
The recipient must prove the gift
A transfer without consideration raises a presumption of resulting trust, because "equity presumes bargains, rather than gifts"; the recipient must prove the transferor's contrary intention on a balance of probabilities (para. 49).
The trial judge stated the law correctly but misapplied it (para. 56). By looking for evidence that William meant to keep an interest, he effectively reversed the onus (para. 42). "It did not fall to the estate to prove that William maintained a beneficial interest in the items and properties; it fell to Gillian to prove that William relinquished any such interest" (para. 62).
Nor could some gifts prove that close to 400 transfers shared "a single, uniform intention" (para. 63).
Section 13: the recipient's word is not enough
Under section 13 of the Evidence Act, in an action by or against the heirs, next of kin, executors, administrators or assigns of a deceased person, an opposite or interested party "shall not obtain a verdict, judgment or decision on his or her own evidence in respect of any matter occurring before the death of the deceased person, unless such evidence is corroborated by some other material evidence." Corroboration must be independent evidence (para. 92).
A relationship can help show donative intent (para. 96), but the trial judge gave it undue prominence (para. 97). Most evidence of it came from Ms. Henry, and "Gillian’s evidence could not corroborate itself" (para. 98). William transferred $800,000 in her first month of employment, before a longstanding relationship could have developed (para. 100). Physical intimacy was "more context than corroboration" (para. 105).
The deceased's own notes matter
The trial judge excluded all but one of William's handwritten notes about the transfers (paras. 65-68). That was an error: necessity was obvious, and "Since William wrote the notes to himself, it is illogical to suggest that he set out to deceive himself" (paras. 83, 85). The new trial judge will decide admissibility and weight (para. 89).
Limitation periods are fact-specific
The trial judge held some claims statute-barred under the two-year Limitations Act, 2002 and the ten-year Real Property Limitations Act (paras. 107-109). The Court set those rulings aside to be decided afresh at the new trial (para. 116). With a resulting trust, the limitation period "might commence on the date of transfer or acquisition, or it might not" (para. 113).
What was upheld, and what changed
Set aside for the new trial: the gift findings (other than VISA card payments), the exclusion of the notes, the limitation rulings, and the fiduciary-duty dismissal (para. 132).
Upheld: William's 80 percent beneficial interest in King of Hearts, a horse-riding stable business (paras. 4, 123, 132); Ms. Henry's liability for certain outstanding loans, including $970,000 owing on a loan (paras. 131-132); and the finding that she cannot keep funds traceable to Phyllis, modified so that $1,938,000 is paid to the estate and then promptly to Phyllis (paras. 131-132).
Who this affects
Estate trustees and families who discover large transfers to a caregiver, companion or friend after a death
People who received significant gifts from someone who has since died
Beneficiaries worried about an estate trustee's handling of assets (see how a court can remove an estate trustee)
Related reading: a resulting trust over an investment property in Harris v. Melo, and the two-year limitation for claims against an estate.
Practical takeaways
For estate trustees and families
Start with the presumption. For a transfer made without anything in return, the recipient must prove a gift (paras. 49, 62).
Preserve the deceased's papers. Notes and file folders can be evidence of intention (paras. 27, 71).
Sort the transfers. Property purchases, debt payments and personal items may tell different stories (paras. 63-64).
Act promptly. Limitation periods can apply; when they start depends on the facts (paras. 107-113).
For people who received gifts
Document intent at the time. Contemporaneous evidence and bank documents can show the giver's intention (para. 51).
Expect to need independent proof. Against an estate, your own evidence about events before the death needs corroboration (paras. 91-92).
Keep records. A lack of loan documents "will not always" support a gift; here, some acknowledged debts were never documented (para. 61).
FAQ
If a parent gave large sums to a caregiver before dying, does the estate have to prove it was not a gift?
No. A transfer made without anything in return is presumed to be held on a resulting trust, and the person who received it must prove, on a balance of probabilities, that the giver intended a gift (paras. 49, 62).
Can the person who received the money simply testify that it was a gift?
Not on their own word alone. Section 13 of Ontario's Evidence Act requires evidence to be corroborated in litigation by or against an estate. In this case, "Gillian’s evidence could not corroborate itself" (paras. 91, 98).
Does a close or romantic relationship prove that the money was a gift?
No. A relationship may help show an intention to give (para. 96), but here it "served as relevant context, but it did not substitute for independent, corroborative evidence of William’s intent" (para. 100).
Can a deceased person's handwritten notes be used as evidence in an estate dispute?
They can be. The Court held that the trial judge erred in excluding most of William's notes; necessity was obvious, and the judge at the new trial will decide admissibility and weight (paras. 83, 89).
Is it too late to challenge transfers made many years before the death?
Not automatically. When a resulting trust is alleged, the limitation period might start on the transfer date, or it might not; the issue is "fundamentally case specific and fact-dependent" (para. 113).
Book a consultation
Francis Lawyers has served Ottawa since 1974. Questioning large transfers, or defending gifts an estate disputes? Our estate litigation lawyers in Ottawa will review the records and the timeline with you. Book a consultation or call (613) 226-1011.
This article is general information, not legal advice. It summarizes a Court of Appeal decision that ordered a new trial; no final finding has been made on whether the transfers were gifts. Published November 17, 2026. Written by the lawyers of Francis Mehr LLP.